Friday, April 20, 2007

Monopolies: Definition Discourse

Because a great portion of my posts focus on the idea of monopolies in a free-market environment, perhaps it is time that we embark on a brief discourse of the issue. This will be the first of the many posts that will follow, providing a critical analysis of the idea of corporate efficiency and coerciveness.

First, as always, let us be clear on what a "monopoly" is. From my personal experience, it has been everything from "a business that can do anything it wants to" to "business that's the best in whatever business they do." For the purposes of objectivity, let us define monopoly as a single seller in a given field. Keep in mind that this definition does not take into account (1) how the monopoly came to be about, (2) the extent of powers and advantages that it has over its competitors, and (3) the venue for obtaining the advantages gained in point #2.

Rockefeller's Standard Oil refined 90% of America's oil in 1899--it was a monopoly. Though not adhering to the aforementioned definition, it can be persuasively argued that 90% did, indeed, constitute a monopolization of the market. Microsoft Corporation's operating system is said to run on 95% of the modern computer systems--as with Rockefeller, Microsoft is considered a monopoly in the modern business context. The United States Postal System, however, has exclusive rights to sell first and third class mail without any threat of private competition--it too is a monopoly, though many, especially the advocates of monopolies constituting the demons of modern society, certainly don't see it as so. Finally, Amtrak, the federally-owned railroad company that has never made a profit in its 32 year old history is certainly a monopoly.

Because of the diversity of businesses and corporations constituting as monopolies, we must assume an objective evaluation to determine whether the "monopoly" is "evil," or, as Nathaniel Branden, author of Question of Monopolies, published in the Intellectual Ammunition Department of The Objectivist Newsletter in June of 1062, put it, whether it has "exclusive control of a given field of production which is closed to and exempt from competition, so that those controlling the field are able to set arbitrary production policies and charge arbitrary pries, independent of the market, immune from the law of supply and demand." Theodore Roosevelt took a similar approach when he distinguished between "good trusts", or, the ones that helped the people, and "bad" trusts, the one that exploited the public (The Northern Securities Company was one of such trusts. It controlled Northern Pacific Railway, Great Northern Railway, Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Railroad and was subsequently dissolved).

Thus, let us look to Mr. Lawrence W. Reed, a scholar at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. According to Reed, "When governments, by one method and to one degree or another, limit competition by means described above, the result is a coercive monopoly for producers who benefit from the limitation of competition." In contrast, the "efficiency" monopoly is one that gets its "high market share not because of any government grant of exclusive privilege, subsidy, special tax treatment, or the like, but because it simply does the best job."

Thus, we can conclude that a monopoly can be either (a) a coercive monopoly or (b) an efficiency monopoly. The USPS is a coercive monopoly--it has exclusive rights to sell and deliver 1st and 3rd class mail not because of its ability to do so at the lowest price, but because the United States government has granted exclusive privileges to the corporation, hampering private corporations from competing and ultimately lowering prices. As my analysis of the USPS found earlier on this blog indicates, because of the government benefits, USPS lacks accountability, is victim to arbitrary price shifts, and is a burden on the U.S. revenue. An efficient monopoly, in contrast, is one that has reached its dominant position on the market through its efficiency and ability to lower the means of production. Walmart is one such monopoly, it has achieved its market position because of its ability to provide the lowest prices, driving the competitors out of business.

Before moving onto our next article, covering (1) the kinds of benefits coercive monopolies are granted and (2) a general outline of the checks provided by free-market economy in impeding the growth of an abusive monopoly, it is crucial that we have a succinct understanding of what a "monopoly" truly means.

Until then, let me know if you have any questions!

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

I for all time emailed thіs ωeb ѕite
post page tο all my аssocіates, sіnce іf like to reaԁ іt
afterwаrd my links will too.

Feel freе to ѵisіt my web page - http://www.online-radioportal.de

Anonymous said...

5. com’s report. Content, keywords and link building are some of the factors using which Search Engine Optimization services are taken care of.
This can be a great tool when selling products online, as a website can be designed
to offer either luxury or bargain-oriented goods, based
on traffic analysis. A dedicated SEO expert will devote
all the attention and effort in enhancing the visibility of your
website or business in the online world. If the conversion is higher with a certain keyword or a particular
set of keywords, then the SEO vendor can focus on
the same keyword to get it ranked high in all the search
engines. Pages and articles are very different, as far as Joomla is
concerned. Relevant keywords ought to be used in the alt
tags. The title is supposed to explain the article, and the title is what your readers see when they search for content.
This helps auto dealership websites rank higher
in the search engines results and get more traffic to the website.
The final way that you can use your Deviant - ART profile
for SEO purposes is by being an active member of the community ' watch the work of others (especially if they are related to your business), encourage others to watch your work, comment on work, list other users as your friends. For instance, how many TV viewers then came to your car lot and purchased a vehicle. The SEO agencies must take care of the fact that the traffic is getting converted to potential customers. You can Google maps link for your website, which will be very helpful if any person search in images sections. These professionals follow ethical SEO strategy and effectively implement it that finally increases your website visibility. G) SEO basics -Image 6: Open Google. You need to try to find reputed SEO consultants. Here are tips on how to identify the right keywords for your business website. And make the work flow smoothly, using good grammar at all times. November 2012.

Feel free to surf to my web blog; click the next page

Anonymous said...

Hi there this is somewhat of off topic but I
was wanting to know if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML.
I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding know-how so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

Stop by my homepage :: internet radio

Anonymous said...

Without the internet, this is not possible to play these novoline games
online and even they can't live online that they perform now with public for additional characteristics and completely attractive in a delusion earth to participate in a game. If you want to enjoy the game thoroughly then you need to get on board of a reliable online bingo site to get the maximum enjoyment as well as benefit of the game. Each child is given 30 seconds to race to the pile and make as many matches as possible before time runs out.

My web page http://theministerstoolkit.com/groups/selecting-convenient-products-of-spiele/
Also see my web site - online radio

Anonymous said...

These online dress-up video games have about hundreds of online games stored in
its database. Does he have certain appointed
times when he is expected to be on-line with
the team. Although others may not have a specific machine for her,
but at least they have most likely computers in
their homes.

Feel free to surf to my web page simply click the following webpage

Anonymous said...

And then, you'll probably see that the battery's charge won't be as durable as before. However, it is still possible to insect the terminals and make sure there is no corrosion. Aside from these types of power packs, you can even choose the 8-cell and also 12-cell electric battery.

Here is my webpage - mirdb.org